Healthy Environment, Healthy Children
  • Home
  • About Me
  • Important Resources
    • HealthyEnvironmentHealthyChildren podcast links
  • Issues
    • How toxic masculinity may bar talented men from the Early Childhood environment
    • Seriously in what universe are we?
    • Yelling
    • On the Importance of Fathers
    • The Pandemic and safety of schools
    • Loss, development, and children
  • Opinions
    • Decreasing Child Poverty
    • The Fallacy of the Mini Approach to Parenting.
    • Mottos and men
    • Children are not Responsible for Social Change
    • Reawakening of a Teacher
    • Firearms and Children
    • Firearms and children: revisited 2022
    • Jimmy Carter's Call to Action
    • What's in a name?
    • When Bullying Happens to the Strongest
  • Bullying Ends Today: The Bullies
    • Disengaged Onlookers
    • Bully Supporters and Followers
    • Defenders and Possible Defenders
    • Bystanders
    • The Role of Parents
    • Power, Control & Bullying
    • I deserved it
    • Bullying and the Hierarchy of Needs
    • The end of bullying and the 6 Core Strengths
  • Bully/Victim Questionnaire
    • Frequency of Bullying
    • Personal Stories of Bullying

The "Race to the Top" will be won by the same students

9/6/2009

8 Comments

 
The NY Times (august 29, 2009) featured an editorial suggesting the lack of support for including student success in calculating a teacher's performance and consequently, pay raises, is "indefensible." In other words, how could you possibly disagree with the idea that student performance alone should be the only measure of a teacher's ability to teach. Well that is what Arne Duncan is proposing in the Department of Education's, Race to the Top program.

I respond in this way; I support a policy that uses student success as the measure of a teacher's ability ONLY if the following factors are considered:

1) ALL teachers have equitable - not equal - access to technology;
2) ALL of our students are fed, clothed, have a roof over their head and financial support at home;
3) ALL of our children have equitable access to counseling in light of the rampant, epidemic nature of their exposure to violence;
4) ALL teachers have equitable access to teaching materials: paper, pencils, scissors, for goodness sakes, a DESK or table spot for ALL the children enrolled in a school:
5) less than 20 children per teacher and language support for all children whose first language is other than English;
6) the physical state of the school site is modern, safe and equipped with modern facilities and the condition of the neighborhood surrounding the school is safe, secure, positive and clean.

If we can provide equitable access to education then I am happy to endorse a teacher incentive plan that uses student success as the barometer for teacher performance. Until that time, creating a national set of standards for all children to meet and then base a teacher's pay on their ability to get their students to perform to those standards are ill-timed and off the point. Furthermore, children arent robots - they have lives and minds of their own and pains and joys, they are individuals with their own direction in life - teachers cant be held accountable for children's performance because they cant control the lives outside the classroom that their students live. I am against a national set of standards and merit pay based on students' ability to meet those national standards. The status quo that the editorial suggests we are trying to keep is that the same group of kids are going to win the "Race to the Top."
8 Comments

    Author

    My passion in life is raising awareness of the factors contributing to the toxic environment in which children live.

    Archives

    October 2013
    April 2012
    February 2012
    February 2011
    February 2010
    January 2010
    December 2009
    October 2009
    September 2009
    August 2009
    July 2009
    June 2009

    Categories

    All
    Assessment
    Bandura
    Behaviorism
    Bullies
    Bully
    Bullying
    Chicago
    Children
    Childrens Defense Fund
    Civil
    Collaboration
    Cooperation And Competition
    Dap
    Dissociation
    Dr. King
    Duncan
    Education
    Effects
    Equity
    Erikson
    Gates Education
    Grade Levels
    Grades
    High School
    Hitting
    Hope
    King
    Law
    Luther
    Martin
    Mike
    National Academic Standards
    Obama
    Oregon
    Parents
    Play
    Poverty
    Psychosocial Development
    Race To The Top
    Reading
    Resiliency
    Respect
    Role Model
    Snap
    Social
    Social Learning Theory
    Spanking
    Standards
    Tacoma
    Tanf
    Target
    Teacher Merit Pay
    Teachers
    Testing
    Therapy
    Tyson

    RSS Feed

Proudly powered by Weebly